You Can't Comp This: NBA Trading Card Podcast

Timeless Moments: The Fake Seal Fallout (Part 2)

Adam Amy & Russell Gibson Season 1 Episode 227

Send us a text

In this follow-up to our first Timeless Moments episode on fake Panini seals, we dive into the hobby’s reaction — and it was LOUD. Russell and Adz break down community feedback, share insights from Sports Card Nonsense and Instagram, and ask the tough questions:

  • Is resealing cards in fake Panini one-touches fraud?
  • Are we the problem for valuing seals too much?
  • And is “raw” really raw if it was once in a PSA slab?

We also hear from the community, including some surprising confessions, and takeaways that might just change how you view sealed cards forever.

This saga’s not just about stickers — it’s about trust, transparency, and what value really means in the hobby.

🎙️ Listen now to hear how this clickbait turned into real talk.



Thank You to our Primary sponsor:
Check Out My Cards Australia and US Sports Cards Australia

Sponsor PROMO: Fast Break Trading Cards
Use the promo code 'YCCT10' for 10% off all Fanatics Memorabilia.

Game Time International: Best Mags In The Hobby

The Hobby Hangout XL: June 1st Click Here For Tickets


Reach out to us on socials and tell us what we got right or wrong!
All of our Socials can be found on our Linktree

You Can't Comp This YouTube - we stream episodes LIVE!
You Can't Comp This on Facebook - join our community